Essential Bakeware for Making the Best Cake

Some people might think that baking a layer cake is too daunting, but we promise anyone can do it if they have the right tools. And we have spent years testing bakeware to determine which is best.

This stand was tall, providing excellent visibility and comfort. It was solid but light, and its surface and base were attached. This made it easy to carry but also meant it couldn’t be submerged in water (although we did just to see what would happen; it still spun perfectly). It rotated quickly and smoothly yet stopped precisely where we asked it to, and it had three shallow circles etched onto its surface for easy centering.

  More on this test

This set was almost perfect: It came with five of our essential tips, including a large open star tip for cupcake swirls and rosettes. The plastic bags were easy to handle, effortless to clean up afterward, and durable (we only once broke a bag, while piping duchess potatoes). Unfortunately, this set lacked a large closed star tip and a coupler. Some pros also thought the 12-inch bags were too small. Most agreed that this is a great starter set if you buy a few extras to round it out.

  More on this test

The deeply beveled edge of this scraper cut through pizza and bread dough quickly and scraped the work surface effectively. The textured polypropylene handle was easy to hold on to, even with greasy or floury hands, and was thinner than other scrapers’ handles, helping us hold it flat to the work surface for easier, more effective scooping and scraping.

  More on this test

These precut parchment sheets, which come in a large plastic zipper-lock bag, are the only ones in our lineup that are stored completely flat. They're also sized just right to slide easily into a standard rimmed baking sheet, although we did have to use two overlapping sheets when rolling jelly roll cakes into coils. Their superior convenience made them the runaway favorite. Don't let the purchase price distract you: The per-sheet cost falls squarely in the middle of our lineup.

  More on this test

This mixer performed exceptionally well. It was speedy, creaming butter and sugar and whipping meringue faster than any other model, and it muscled through dense cookie dough with ease. Its beater heads are the widest in the lineup, making for efficient mixing and zero clogging, and they’re rubber-tipped, so they didn’t clang around in the bowl. This mixer is thoughtfully designed with several features that make mixing more efficient and convenient, including a timer, a light that shines into the mixing bowl, a pause button, a well-positioned display screen, and a plastic storage case that locks onto its base.

  More on this test

Once we got past our initial total confusion about how this innovative stand mixer works—its design is radically different from the familiar KitchenAid style—we quickly began to appreciate its powerful performance, excellent visibility, sturdy parts, and easy handling. Made in Sweden since 1940, the Ankarsrum (pronounced on-kar-SHROOM) had a thick manual that was difficult for beginners; it referred users to YouTube videos. After a short, steep learning curve, we found using this mixer quite easy. It aced our tests, whipping just two egg whites into airy, stiff peaks; creaming cake batter and cookie dough; and effortlessly kneading pizza and bagel bread doughs. It is large with a lot of parts to store, but if you have the space, it’s an ideal choice for serious home bakers who often make big batches that require heavy-duty mixing, though it performs well on smaller tasks too. One note: The top of the bowl is open, with its high-torque motor in the base of the machine. It’s very important to keep tools and fingers out of the fascinating and vigorous mixing action. You actually flip the mixer on its side to attach and operate additional tools.

  More on this test

“Wow” kept appearing in our notes: Butter and sugar creamed to fluffy heaps, cake batter was “smooth as silk,” and bread dough was “gorgeous and elastic.” We enjoyed the generous capacity; weighty stability; and big, uncoated stainless-steel attachments of this updated 7-quart model. It offers 11 speeds (shades of “Spinal Tap”), including a “half speed” for folding delicate ingredients. It easily whipped just two egg whites but also powered through big double batches of pizza dough and stiff bread dough and sailed through abuse testing to produce 12 extra batches of bread and pizza dough in a row. It came with three paddle blades, including one with silicone fins, which saved us scraping down the bowl. The whisk’s many wire loops and flattened shape rode close to the bowl, engaging fully with even small amounts of ingredients (we liked that the tool height was adjustable). The “redesigned premium touchpoints” in its name is a grand way to refer to large brushed-steel control knobs (a tester with bigger hands noted they were particularly easy to grab). The bowl has a comfortable, vertical handle that provided a secure grip for pouring and scraping out batter. This substantial mixer takes up a lot of room and is heavy; bear this in mind if you plan to move your mixer often. That said, we have a big caveat with this and all other KitchenAid mixers. The company has outlined strict speed and time limits for kneading: Kneading with the dough hook over speed 2 is not recommended. (A sticker covering the end of the hook reinforced this point.) This meant that when recipes called for speeds such as “medium-high” or “high,” we had to stick with speed 2. It took longer, but the results were still excellent. However, KitchenAid also states that you should not knead, even on speed 2, for longer than 2 minutes at a time without resting the mixer, and the total mixing time should not exceed 4 to 6 minutes. We think this is a major drawback to what was otherwise an excellent mixer, and we are concerned about its durability.

  More on this test