America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo
Cooking Tips

How to Prevent Your Onions from Slipping Through the Grill Grates

 For onions that are close to (but not directly in) the fire. 

Published July 15, 2022.

Grilled onions are the perfect complement to your favorite burger and can even stand alone as a side dish. These tasty textural components absorb the smoky essence of the grill on the inside while taking on a lovely char on the outside. 

But grilling onions can be tricky. The layers often come apart; they’re prone to burning; and they can easily slip from your tongs through the grates, quickly incinerating in the flames.  

Here are three ways to make sure that your grilled onions make it to the plate.

Sign up for the Notes from the Test Kitchen newsletter

Our favorite tips and recipes, enjoyed by 2 million+ subscribers!

1. Cut thick slices, wedges, or halves.

Option 1: Slice onions into thick, ½-inch rounds. This provides greater surface area and makes them easier to move around so that they don’t burn on the outside while staying raw on the inside.  

Option 2: Slice onions into wedges and leave the root end intact. We used this method in our Grilled Panzanella Salad for beautifully cooked red onions with eye-catching char lines. 

Option 3: Half the onions pole to pole, which is how we keep our Grilled Onions with Balsamic Vinaigrette intact (and control the charring).

2. Skewer them.

Thread sliced onions onto a metal skewer, taking care to thread the skewer through each onion layer. This is a great way to keep the onions intact for the cooking process. No skewers? Run two toothpicks through the center of the slices or wedges for similar results. 

400+ Grilling Recipes!

Master of the Grill

Whether you’re new to grilling or consider yourself a genuine pit master, Master of the Grill is perfect for you. We've divided this book into three sections (The Basics, The Easy Upgrades, and Serious Projects) to help you find recipes that suit your level of grilling.

3. Grip the onions, not the skewer.

Onions have a tendency to burn over high heat, and they need to cook for a long time. Grilling them often requires moving them around every few minutes to ensure that they don’t stick or burn in a hot spot.

When moving your onion skewers, grip a slice at or near the center rather than struggle with the skewer handle. You’ll have an easier time flipping with more surface area and run less risk of the slices sliding off the skewer and into the flames.

This is a members' feature.