America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo

Buying a Lobster? Why You Should Ask the Fishmonger to Give It a Squeeze 

You can (and should) judge a lobster by its shell. 

Published Sept. 21, 2022.

There’s more to lobster than just looks. It’s important to know how it feels.

Give your lobster a squeeze.

The quality of lobster meat depends to a large extent on where the crustacean is in its molting cycle, the period during which the hard, old shell is replaced with a soft, new one. You can determine the stage of your lobster with a gentle squeeze. A soft shell will yield to pressure. A hard shell won’t.

Sign up for the Notes from the Test Kitchen newsletter

Our favorite tips and recipes, enjoyed by 2 million+ subscribers!

When shopping for lobster, the harder the shell, the better. Hard-shell lobsters taste better and are meatier.

The shell also gives away the lobster's gender.


Fresh, modern flavors, 175+ recipes that accommodate multiple kinds of fish, and plenty of fish facts will inspire you to dive into seafood cookery with confidence.

There is no discernible difference in taste between a male or female lobster. But let’s say you’re a fan of roe. In that case, you’ll want to look for a female lobster. You can do this by feeling the legs of the lobster. Her soft “swimmerets,” or the appendages under the lowest legs, give her away. A male's swimmerets will feel harder than the female's.

So go ahead and judge a lobster by its shell. We encourage it.

This is a members' feature.