Cooking Tips

7 Tips for Successful Soup Making

Follow our kitchen-tested tips for flavorful and hearty soup, every time.

Published Oct. 10, 2022.

To make sure that every spoonful of soup is richly flavored, with juicy meat and/or tender vegetables, follow these kitchen-tested tips.

1. Use a Sturdy Pot

It is worth investing in a heavy pot with a thick bottom to use for making soup. It will transfer heat evenly and prevent scorching, which can impart a burnt flavor to your soup.

Equipment Review

The Best Dutch Ovens

Dutch ovens do it all. But which pot makes “it all” easiest?
See Our Winner

2. Sauté the Aromatics

The first step in making many soups is to sauté aromatic vegetables such as onions and garlic. Sautéing not only softens their texture so that there is no unwelcome crunch in the soup but also tames any harsh flavors and develops more-complex flavors in the process. Medium heat is usually a good temperature for sautéing.

Sign up for the Notes from the Test Kitchen newsletter

Our favorite tips and recipes, enjoyed by 2 million+ subscribers!

3. Start with Good Broth

A soup tastes like what you put into it. In minimally seasoned soups where the broth takes center stage, we almost always use homemade—you can use your Instant Pot to make broth in record time. However, in most cases, good store-bought broth (and even broth concentrate) is a fine and convenient option. Please note: Differences among packaged broths are significant.

Equipment Review

Chicken Broth

Just about every broth in the supermarket amounts to a science project of flavor enhancers and salt. Does that have to be a bad thing?
See Our Winner

4. Cut Vegetables to the Right Size

Most soups call for chunks of vegetables. Haphazardly cut vegetables will cook unevenly—some pieces will be underdone and crunchy while others will be mushy. Cutting the vegetables to the size specified ensures that all the pieces will be perfectly cooked.

400 Recipes, 200 Skills

New Cooking School: Fundamentals

No matter what stage you’re at in your culinary journey, you'll learn new techniques and recipes in this tell-all cookbook. You’ll be able to ensure the success of each recipe with helpful highlights and step photos as well as troubleshooting checklists.

5. Stagger the Addition of Vegetables

When a soup contains a variety of vegetables, their addition to the pot must often be staggered to account for their varying cooking times. Dense vegetables such as potatoes and winter squash can withstand much more cooking than delicate asparagus or spinach.

Hearty Minestrone

Italians rely on garden-ripe vegetables, but most of us need to make do with supermarket pickings. Is a soup with fresh, bright flavors still possible?
Get the Recipe

6. Keep Liquid at a Simmer

The fine line between simmering and boiling makes a big difference. A simmer is a restrained boil; fewer bubbles break the surface, and they do so with less vigor. Simmering heats food more gently and more evenly; boiling causes vegetables such as potatoes to break apart or fray at the edges, and it can toughen meat, too.

Creamy White Bean Soup with Herb Oil and Crispy Capers

Soup made with canned beans is convenient and satisfying. But can it be sophisticated, too? Surprisingly, yes.
Get the Recipe

7. Season Just Before Serving

The saltiness of the broth and other ingredients, such as canned tomatoes and canned beans, can vary greatly, so it's always best to taste and adjust the seasoning (salt as well as pepper, delicate herbs, and fresh citrus) just before ladling the soup into bowls for serving.

Photo: Kathrin Ziegler, Getty Images

This is a members' feature.