I don’t think this is a hot take: Cookies are better than candy. Who wouldn’t rather bite into a homemade, gooey, warm cookie than even the best mass-produced candy bar?
Turn Your Leftover Halloween Candy into the Best Cookies Ever
Sign up for the Cook's Country Dinner Tonight newsletter
10 ingredients. 45 minutes. Quick, easy, and fresh weeknight recipes.
So at a time of year with a surplus of candy in my life, my mind gravitates to a wonderfully adaptable cookie recipe developed by my co-worker Mark Huxsoll.
For this recipe, you start with a base of flour, melted butter, brown and granulated sugars, eggs, vanilla, baking soda, and salt. This recipe has a slightly higher amount of baking soda than the average cookie recipe and calls for baking the cookies in a 425-degree oven. The combination of extra leavener and a hot oven makes the cookies soufflé in the oven and collapse on themselves. It sounds chef-y (or maybe like a mistake), but the end result is a cookie with a delightful mix of a crispy exterior and a gooey, barely cooked inside. And this technique keeps the cookies chewy and fresh-tasting for a couple days after baking.
Loaded Triple Chocolate Chunk CookiesA great cookie base loaded with three kinds of chocolate.
With this basic formula, the world is your proverbial oyster (though I doubt oysters would be good in a cookie). Once you mix the dough, you can add 1½ cups of just about any mix-ins—including all that halloween candy—into the cookie dough before baking.
I’d stick to chocolate- or nut-based candies, but otherwise, have fun with it.
Mark made versions with chopped mixed chocolate; marshmallows, milk chocolate, and graham crackers; and, my personal favorite, Reeses pieces and cooked bacon. Yes, Mark put bacon in a cookie—and the result was delightfully salty and sweet. You can chop up Snickers and peanuts or Twix and caramel chips or just a mix of whatever chocolate candy you have.
Loaded Peanut Butter-Bacon CookiesA great cookie base loaded with bacon and Reese's Pieces.
I promise you, your kids won’t be sad to trade their halloween candy for these cookies.