America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo
Baking Tips

5 Mistakes to Avoid While Working with Puff Pastry

Frozen puff pastry can be the fast track to a wide array of scrumptious, flaky dishes—but if you’re not careful, it can bake up soggy, greasy, or flat.
By

Published Mar. 21, 2024.

5 Mistakes to Avoid While Working with Puff Pastry

When you have a box of frozen puff pastry on hand, you’ve got a head start on a wide array of dishes, from flaky appetizers to buttery desserts to main courses such as our Upside-Down Tomato Tart—but if you’re not careful, you may inadvertently inhibit your puff’s performance.

Here are five common mistakes to avoid while working with this freezer aisle favorite.

Sign up for the Cook's Insider newsletter

The latest recipes, tips, and tricks, plus behind-the-scenes stories from the Cook's Illustrated team.

Mistake #1: Trying to Speed Up the Thawing Time

We’ve all been there: You forgot to pull your puff pastry out of the freezer ahead of time, and now you’re considering leaving the box on the countertop to thaw more quickly. Resist the temptation!

You can thaw puff pastry on the counter if your kitchen is cool, but you risk overheating it. The safest bet is always to defrost it slowly in the fridge.

Mistake #2: Rolling Over the Dough's Edges

Watch where you roll: When rolling out your dough to the correct size, make sure you don’t roll over the edges of the sheet. Flattening the edges inhibits the “puff.”

Mistake #3: Using a Dull Knife

Along the same lines, a too-dull knife will also pinch the puff pastry’s edges together—to preserve the flaky layers, you need a knife or bench scraper with a keen blade to make clean, precise cuts.

Taste Test

The Best Store-Bought Puff Pastry

Quality puff pastry can help create show-stopping treats at home. Which store-bought product bakes up best?
Read Our Review

Mistake #4: Baking Immediately After Shaping and Cutting

If you pop your pastry directly into the oven after you’ve cut and shaped it, you risk the butter melting too quickly and leaking out. Just a 15 to 30 minute chilling period in the fridge before baking will firm the butter and help retain flakiness.

Mistake #5: Tossing Your Leftovers

If you thaw more puff pastry than you need for your recipe, you needn’t waste it: Simply refreeze what’s left over.

In testing, we’ve found that there is little difference between dough frozen once and dough frozen twice; pastry made with all butter (rather than butter and shortening) won’t rise quite as high after a double freeze, but the effect is minimal.

Recipes That Use Puff Pastry

Put your frozen puff pastry to work in these easy, satisfying recipes.

Recipe

Chicken Pot Pie with Spring Vegetables

This recipe uses an innovative technique to keep the puff pastry from getting soggy on top of the pot pie.
Get the Recipe
Recipe

Caramelized Onion, Tomato, and Goat Cheese Tart

Frozen puff pastry provides a light, crisp crust in this simple recipe.
Get the Recipe
Recipe

Everything Bagel Pigs in Blankets

Puff pastry brings these from the kids' table to cocktail hour.
Get the Recipe

0 Comments

This is a members' feature.