But most of us don’t, and that’s fine. Because there are plenty of quick and easy ways to up your pie pastry game that don’t require pro-caliber skills or hours of intricate sculpting. All you need is a great dough recipe, common kitchen tools (even basic flatware works), a sharp knife, and some sugar.
Read on to learn how easy it is to make pie even prettier and more appealing.
Sign up for the Cook's Insider newsletter
The latest recipes, tips, and tricks, plus behind-the-scenes stories from the Cook's Illustrated team.
1. Design an Edgier Edge
Embellishing the edges of the crust—single or double—is a surprisingly simple way to upgrade the appearance of your pie. Chill the dough for 15 minutes before edging to make neater marks.
FOR A FLUTED EDGE: Cut edges of dough with fluted pastry wheel.
FOR A SCALLOPED EDGE
- Line tip of inverted spoon up with inside edge of lip of plate, with spoon handle facing out.
- Press spoon firmly into dough to leave behind indentation.
- Shift spoon so tip is halfway between inside and outside edge of plate’s lip, and press firmly into dough to leave second indentation. Repeat evenly around edge of pie.
FOR A CRIMPED EDGE: Use tines of fork or serrated knife (hold blade parallel to counter and press scalloped edges into dough) to fringe border.
FOR A ROPE EDGE:
- Holding body of 1/4-inch-wide round chopstick at 45-degree angle to edge of plate, firmly press chopstick into dough.
- Repeat pressing chopstick into dough evenly around the edge of pie, leaving ½ inch between each mark.
2. Make the Crust Shine and Sparkle
Brushing the top crust with egg wash (or water) and sprinkling it with sugar gives the pastry lustrous browning and shimmer—and the effect can be really impressive when you liberally apply both. Thoroughly moistening the dough enables it to grasp lots of sugar, which transforms into a candy-like layer with brilliant sheen, crackly crunch, and notable sweetness that pairs particularly well with tart fruit fillings such as rhubarb, apricot, plum, and sour cherry.
You can use any kind of sugar, but the effect will differ.
- Granulated: Finer, more delicate crispness and uniform sheen
- Demerara or Turbinado: Coarser crunch and more sequin-like sparkle
How to Add Sparkle to a 9-Inch Pie
- WASH CRUST: Beat 1 egg with pinch of salt. (Salt will loosen the egg proteins and make the wash more fluid and easier to brush evenly over the dough.) Using pastry brush, thoroughly paint surface with 1 to 2 tablespoons wash. (Alternatively, use 2 tablespoons water instead of egg wash.)
- SPRINKLE SUGAR: Before cutting vents, sprinkle 2 to 3 tablespoons sugar (depending on the sweetness of the filling) evenly over surface.
3. Cut Distinctive Vents
- Using a sharp paring knife, make a slash (or a series of them in a simple pattern) on the top of the dough. If making multiple pies, use a different design for each flavor to help tell them apart.
- For more visual appeal, insert the knife into the vent and wiggle it side to side to widen the vent slightly.
- Use a small decorative cutter, biscuit cutter, or spice jar lid to punch out small shapes from the dough.
- For more visual appeal, save a few cutouts to decorate intact areas of crust, brushing their undersides with water and pressing gently but firmly to adhere.