These mini Key lime pies are cute, custardy, citrusy delights!
SMASH: Add graham cracker pieces to large zipper-lock plastic bag. Seal bag, making sure to press out all air. Use rolling pin to gently pound bag to break crackers into crumbs.
MIX: Add graham cracker crumbs and butter to small bowl. Heat in microwave until toasted, about 1 minute. Stir with rubber spatula to combine.
SOFTEN: In large bowl, microwave cream cheese for 10 to 15 seconds. Whisk softened cream cheese until very smooth.
WHISK: Add condensed milk, lime zest and juice, water, egg yolk, and salt to bowl with cream cheese. Whisk until well combined and smooth.
BAKE AND COOL: Bake until filling is set and no longer jiggles when baking sheet is gently shaken, about 6 minutes. Let key lime cups cool on cooling rack for 45 minutes.
Key limes are NOT the same as the limes you see in the supermarket! Key limes are smaller and have more seeds, a thinner skin, and a tarter taste. They get their name from the Florida Keys, where they were first grown. Don’t worry, you don’t have to hunt down key limes, even though these are called “Key Lime Cups”—we developed this recipe with regular Persian limes!