Caramel Turtle Icebox Pie

7 comments

Turtles showcase the ultimate combination of contrasting flavors and textures—smooth, deep chocolate; sweet, chewy caramel; and rich, crunchy nuts—and to us, they are candy perfection. So we made a pie form.

A cookbook recipe exclusively for All-Access members from The Perfect Pie

SERVES8 to 10

TIME30 minutes, plus 2½ hours chilling

Caramel Turtle Icebox Pie
The Perfect Pie

A cookbook recipe exclusively for All-Access members from The Perfect Pie

WHY THIS RECIPE WORKS

We decided to make a turtle in pie form. For the base we opted for a chocolate cookie crust, which was only mildly sweet so the pie could handle a rich filling and a thick pecan-caramel sauce. Rather than reserve the sauce for the top, we d...

Print