Reviews you can trust.See why.
The Best White Chocolate Chips
With so many products and so many different names, shopping for white chocolate can be confusing. We sampled six to find a versatile winner.
Top PicksSee Everything We Tested
What You Need To Know
In the test kitchen, we love white chocolate chips for the pops of creamy sweetness they bring to cookies, brownies, and bars. We also like melting them into mousse, bark, frosting, and even fruit tart filling. But since they’re sold under many different names, from white chocolate chips to white chips to baking wafers to white morsels, considering all the options can make your head spin. If a recipe calls for white chocolate chips, does it matter which product you buy?
What Is White Chocolate?
First, let’s clarify what white chocolate really is. Like all chocolate, it begins with cacao pods. After the cacao beans are harvested from the pods, they are fermented, dried, cleaned, and roasted. Next, the shells are removed from the beans, revealing cacao nibs, which are ground into a paste called chocolate liquor. This liquor is divided into two parts: cocoa butter and cocoa solids. Cocoa butter is responsible for the richness we associate with chocolate. Though cocoa butter has some chocolaty flavor and aroma, cocoa solids are responsible for most of chocolate’s flavor as well as its color and aroma. White chocolate, unlike other types of chocolate, contains only cocoa butter. That’s why it’s so light in color.
According to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), white chocolate must have at least 20 percent cocoa butter (in addition to meeting certain requirements for milk solids, milk fat, and sweeteners). Many products replace some—or all—of that cocoa butter with refined fats: palm kernel oil, palm oil, or a combination of the two. These products can’t legally be called white chocolate. Instead, they’re labeled white baking wafers, white morsels, or white melting chips. (For simplicity, we’ve chosen to refer to all these products as “white chips.”)
We gathered six nationally available products, four imitation and two real, priced from about $0.25 to about $1.10 per ounce. We tasted them plain and in Wintermint Bark (without the peppermint topping, which we found distracting), to find the best product for a variety of recipes.
Flavor Battle: White Chocolate Chips versus White Chips
Our tasters picked up on flavor differences among the products. Like good dark and milk chocolates, the real white chocolate samples were described as complex, with most tasters enjoying their milky, nutty, and vanilla flavors. Others called out sour or citrusy notes that they found off-putting. Responses to the white chips were much more uniform. For the most part, these products offered mild yet pleasant hints of vanilla, caramel, and butterscotch and were moderately sweet (one was very sweet). To our surprise, all the white chips...
Everything We Tested
Tasters said the bark made with these real white chocolate chips was “way too soft” and “not snappy like bark at all.” However, our tasters liked the chips’ “creamy” texture when eating them plain and described their flavor as “milky,” “nutty,” and “complex,” though a few found it a little “citrusy” and “sour.”
Some tasters enjoyed the “nutty” and “vanilla” flavors and the “creamy,” “rich” texture of these real white chocolate chips. A few reported “sour” and “citrus” notes. This sample did not perform well in bark because it contains cocoa butter; instead of setting up, it remained “squishy” and “too soft.”
Reviews you can trust
The mission of America’s Test Kitchen Reviews is to find the best equipment and ingredients for the home cook through rigorous, hands-on testing.
Carolyn is a senior editor for ATK Reviews. She's a French-trained professional baker.